A while ago, David Samuels wrote in New York Times magazine—and I quote—"It is a shared if
unspoken premise of the world that most of us inhabit that absolutes do not exist and that people who claim to
have found them are crazy."
Being the "crazy" person that I am, I honestly don't understand the following tenants of the truly tolerant like Mr. Samuels.
"There is no such thing as absolute truth."
Help me understand this. You're saying it's absolutely true that there's no absolute truth. And if that's true, how can you be sure your statement is truth?
"I only believe what I can perceive with my five senses."
Hmmm? Can you prove that statement by sight, smell, hearing, touch, or taste? I don't think so.
"What is right and wrong are for the individual to decide."
Okay, so rapper R. Kelly, who allegedly had child pornography on his computer, shouldn't be harassed by intolerant authorities because pictures of naked 12-year-olds are "right" for him? And that wacky Iraqi, Saddam Hussein, is simply expressing his individuality by using chemical weapons on his own people and taking his sons out for a night of torturing political prisoners.
Aren't there some things that are always wrong for everyone? And if you say "yes," aren't you admitting to a "moral absolute"? If you say "no," I'm assuming it's okay with you if I steal your wallet.
"Well, right and wrong is what a society decides it is."
Hmmm? So slavery was right for thousands of years until society recently decided it wasn't? How about segregation? Was that just fine until a majority in Congress decided it wasn't in 1964? And why are we hassling societies of China, North Korea, and Sudan for the torture and murder of religious minorities?
"No, something is wrong if it hurts other people."
Wait a minute. I thought you said there were no moral absolutes? Is that always true for all cultures? Aren't suicide bombers in the Middle East idolized as moral heroes by a part of society?
And how 'bout the person in a mask who comes up to you, knocks you unconscious, slashes open your chest, and takes all your money? Of course I'm talking about a cardiologist. So, isn't some pain good for us? Isn't "hurt" an absolute concept? And what about sado-masochism?
"Well, you shouldn't try to change other people's beliefs."
But what if I disagree with that statement? Aren't you trying to change my beliefs?
Let me get this straight, it's "right" for you to try to convince me of your ideas about "no absolute truth" and "individual morality," but it's "wrong" for me to try to take my beliefs out into the arena of public debate?
"You're just intolerant!
So, you're saying I'm "intolerant" for voicing my beliefs, but you're "tolerant" for rejecting my views as "intolerant"?
Hmmm? Are you absolutely sure about that?!
(c) 2003 James N. Watkins
Related articles
Yep, I'm intolerant!
'Absolutes without Absolutism' from BreakPoint.org
Related quote
"No one is actually a real relativist, including the contemporary secular liberal. Secularists today make a
whole host of moral judgments, and they do so unhesitantly. They invoke relativism when arguing against
Christians and other cultural conservatives. But they treat their own beliefs and moral principles as objective,
absolute, and universal truths." Brad Stetson and Joseph Conti in The Truth about Tolerance (InterVarsity Press)
Leave a comment, tell a friend, send me money . . .
Email your comments to jim@jameswatkins.com.
And if this page was helpful, please . . .
a) save it as a favorite at
delicious.com
b) subscribe to the RSS feed
c) recommend it to digg.com and
StumbleUpon.com and
d) tell a friend:
And if this page was really helpful, please . . .
e) please consider a donation to our sponsor XarisCom.
You can donate securely with any major credit card through PayPal. Thanks!
Legal stuff and warnings
Copyright © James Watkins. All text and graphics on my sites, unless otherwise noted, are copyrighted © in my name,
James N. Watkins, and are protected by United States copyright law and international copyright law under the Berne
Convention. Please visit the press room for information on reprinting any text or
graphics. Thanks!
WARNING: Reader assumes full responsibility for the proper and prescribed use of this
site. For external use only. Discontinue if rash, redness, irritation, or swelling develops. If swallowed, do not
induce vomiting. Side-effects may include drowsiness or mild to severe agitation. Do not read while consuming alcohol or
operating heavy machinery. Keep away from open flame. Do not store above 451 degrees. Do not use near or place in water.
Void where prohibited, taxed or licensed. Any medical information provided is for general educational use only and should
not be used as a substitute for professional medical advice.
Views expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of
any other person—real or fictitious, living or dead—using the name James
N. Watkins.
